An indian challenge to western universalism, indra s net. He is currently the arvind raghunathan professor of south asian studies at the department of middle eastern, south asian, and african studies at columbia university. This book examines three closely related questions in the process of canon formation in the sikh tradition. This book has nothing to do with converting others. There is a detailed discussion in the indianamerican scholar rajiv malhotras book, indras net. Wikipedia page of the book being different an indian challenge to western universalism, thinker and philosopher rajiv malhotra addresses the challenge of a direct and honest engagement on differences, by reversing the gaze, repositioning india from being the observed to the observer and looking at the west from. Dec 20, 2014 especially when you see contradictions between what he says in the book and what he actually does. Donigers massive pr machinery went to work overtime to put the matter in the limelight of world news. The book reverts the gaze of the western cultures on india, repositioning india from being the observed to the observer, by looking at the west from a dharmic. The book has circulated very well and we are honoured to be its south asian publisher. It is a kind of position only a great poet or a visionary is capable of taking. Online resource, database, crowd sourcing, and expert feedback on contemporary hinduism, dharmic india, and topics covered in breaking india, being different. There can be no single universalism, even if it assimilates or, in the author s words, digests, elements from other civilizations kapila vatsyayan. An indian challenge to western universalism 2011 is important for two reasons.
There is a detailed discussion in the indianamerican scholar rajiv malhotra s book, indra s net. Erudite and engaging, being different critiques fashionable reductive. After four years of litigation, an outofcourt settlement was recently reached under which penguin agreed to withdraw the book from india. Checkout this document created by a reader to understand the core ideas from chapter 5 nontranslatable sanskrit versus digestion of the book.
Review rajiv malhotra, authour of being different hopes to set the terms for a deeper and more informer engagement between dharmic and western civilizations. The indian challenge to western universalism, currently under discussion in the blogosphere at the patheos book club, explores presuppositions in the. A rebuttal to rajiv malhotra, by an elite leftist goon. Dec 02, 2011 rajiv malhotra debates mark tully, eminent bbc correspondent who has lived most of his life in india and is highly regarded as a lover of indian civilization. It is also a unique civilization with philosophies and cosmologies that are. The most common sanskrit phrase quoted in this regard, often repeated at popular gatherings, is vasudhaiva kutumbakam, which means, the world is. I am posting here an excerpt from rajiv malhotra s book. Rajeev malhotras upcoming book academic hinduphobia will be available in july, 2016. Having said that, i do recommend this book being different, to understand many aspects of hindu dharmic traditions that are often misunderstood. A rebuttal to rajiv malhotra, by an elite leftist goon activist. Select any poster below to play the movie, totally free. Rajiv malhotra books store online buy rajiv malhotra.
An indian challenge to western universalism, thinker and philosopher rajiv malhotra addresses the challenge of a direct and honest engagement on differences, by reversing the gaze, repositioning india from being the observed to the observer and looking at the west from the dharmic point of view. So first we should understand what rajiv malhotra means by western universalism. An indianamerican entrepreneur, philanthropist and community leader, he has devoted himself, for the last ten years, to clarifying the many misperceptions about indic traditions in america and amongst indians. Especially when you see contradictions between what he says in the book and what he actually does. An indian challenge to western universalism, indras net. An indian challenge to western universalism, thinker, and philosopher rajiv malhotra addresses the challenge of a direct and honest engagement on differences, by reversing the gaze, repositioning india from being the observed to the observer and looking at the west from the dharmic point of view. Rajiv malhotra s insistence on preserving difference with mutual respect not with mere tolerance is even more pertinent today because the notion of a single universalism is being propounded. There can be no single universalism, even if it assimilates or, in the author s words, digests, elements from other civilizations kapila.
Defending hinduism s philosophical unity, the battle for sanskrit, and the newly released book academic hinduphobia. Rajiv malhotra debates mark tully, eminent bbc correspondent who has lived most of his life in india and is highly regarded as a lover of indian civilization. It is available for preorder at his official website rajiv. Being different speaks to us about a revolutionary change in thought that is in motion within indic civilization, because it demonstrates how some of its most thoughtful members are breaking with a deepseated tradition of western colonialist thought and scholarship.
Rajiv malhotra shares foreword of his book academic. Jul 17, 2015 upset about rajiv malhotras plagiarism, even more upset about distortions of my work. Rajiv malhotra is doing some really good work no doubt. Find link is a tool written by edward betts longer titles found. Tribes, regions, races, and religious groups fought one another often, but no strife was permanent. He was the general editor of the clay sanskrit library and is the founding editor of the murty. An indian challenge to western universalism, thinker and philosopher rajiv malhotra addresses the challenge of a direct and honest engagement on differences, by reversing the gaze, repositioning india from being the observed to the observer. The inner attributed to the dharmic cultures which tend to be more accepting of difference, unpredictability and uncertainty. The mental uneasiness caused by the perception of difference combined with a desire to diminish, conceal or eradicate it. The most common sanskrit phrase quoted in this regard, often repeated at popular gatherings, is vasudhaiva kutumbakam, which means, the world is one family.
An indian challenge to western universalism is a 2011 book by rajiv malhotra, an indianamerican author, philanthropist and public speaker, published by harpercollins. Subramaniam swamy was keynote speaker to honor rajiv malhotra, author of the best selling book, breaking india 2011 in bengaluru, nov 20, 2011. Checkout vibhinnata laghu sanskaran summary of book vibhinnata. Being different rajiv malhotra infinity foundation. The very acts of recursion and reiteration after a. Rajiv malhotra is the founder and president of infinity foundation. The straw man fallacy and the battle for sanskrit hindu. It challenges western categories of knowledge as well as. Some reflections on rajiv malhotras being different gerald james larson let me begin by reiterating what i said in my prepublication comments about the book, namely, that rajiv malhotras being different. Rajiv malhotra is back with another book bound to create a. While the notion that western scholarship is out to demean ancient indian learning is bound to find many takers, heres a book that reveals poetry by a relatively.
Pollock is a scholar of sanskrit, the intellectual and literary history of india, and comparative intellectual history. Have you read the book rajiv malhotras book being different. Breaking india western interventions in dravidian and dalit faultlines publisher. Untangling the false knots in rajiv malhotras indras net. Graphic novel hindi history holiday gift guide mindbodyspirit others poetry politics.
Check out the indian movies with the highest ratings from imdb users, as well as the movies that are trending in real time. Home being different the bookbeing different the book. Mark tully discusses rajiv malhotras book being different. My opinion is shaped by rajiv malhotras book being different which i am currently reading. Rajiv malhotra has explained them very well in this book with the help of simple tables and charts. Prime minister narendra modis dream of a cashless economy is achievable. I agree with him that the euroamerican gaze directed at asia has not only been destruc. Being different rajiv malhotra harpercollins india. The holy spirit is not the same as shakti america magazine. Im bothered by his love for ramdev since ramdev is blatantly antilgbt, whom i also dont consider anything more than a goon who is capital shame for the saffron robe. Nov 24, 2015 rajiv malhotra s insistence on preserving difference with mutual respect not with mere tolerance is even more pertinent today because the notion of a single universalism is being propounded.
A critique of rajiv malhotras being different, international journal of hindu studies, springer netherlands, 16 the destiny of me 620 words view diff no match in snippet view article find links to article. Praise for being different by rajiv malhotra this highly original book leads its reader on an epic journey of selfdiscovery especially for those of us in the west. Rajiv malhotra s latest book, being different, is at this the forefront of this renaissance. Rajiv malhotra s being different is a path breaking book filled with original perspectives on both indian and western civilizations. Rajiv malhotras insistence on preserving difference with mutual respect not. Gier rajiv malhotra has been a leading spokesperson defending the indian. On imdb tv, you can catch hollywood hits and popular tv series at no cost. The term difference anxiety as defined by shri rajiv malhotra in his book being different is as follows. Rajiv malhotras being different 4 comments on this key principle of ayurveda in a book section that explains the reasons behind an inherent indic comfort with chaos.
The model of the indras net employed by the atharvan seer or the later buddhist sage as set forth in rajiv malhotras book bearing the same title is a telling case in point. Tbfs is rajiv malhotras latest book, in which he offers a much needed analysis of a subversive and pseudoscientific variety of scholarship epitomized by the likes of sheldon. Murdered for being different searching for being different 527 found 808 total alternate case. Upset about rajiv malhotras plagiarism, even more upset.
For a critique of western universalism, read rajiv malhotras book being different this is not to suggest that the precolonial eras were times of peaceful coexistence between people. Online shopping from a great selection at books store. But the terms agreed to do not ban electronic copies or foreign editions from being sold in india. An indian challenge to western universalism, thinker, and philosopher rajiv malhotra addresses the challenge of a direct and honest engagement on differences, by reversing the gaze, repositioning india from being the observed to the observer.
Its concerns are mainly metaphysical, cultural and civilizational. Mar 01, 2012 rajiv malhotras new book, being different. An indian challenge to western universalism is a 2011 book by rajiv malhotra, an indianamerican author, philanthropist and public speaker. Rajiv malhotra born 15 september 1950 is an indianamerican author who, after a career in the computer and telecom industries, took early retirement in 1995 to set up the infinity foundation, which focuses on indic studies, and also funds projects such as columbia university s project to translate the tibetan buddhist tengyur. Early in the first 50 pages that are constantly driven by this mutual respect theme, malhotra asks a lutheran minister, is the lutheran doctrine merely to tolerate other religions or also to the subtitle of being different is an indian challenge to western universalism. The best part of malhotras book is his discussion of a general dharma ethics that would adapt to different temperaments and life circumstances 2011.
By west, the author refers to those culture families which originated w. Upset about rajiv malhotras plagiarism, even more upset about distortions of my work. Indias integrity is being undermined by three global networks that have wellestablished operating bases inside india. Rajiv malhotra s lecture on academic colonization delivered at uberoi foundation 2010 we use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. The same kind of contextual sensitivity is shown in preparations of herbal medicine, as well as in medical diagnosis and prescription. Is sanskrit political or sacred, oppressive or liberating, dead or alive. Gier rajiv malhotra has been a leading spokesperson defending the indian philosophical and religious traditions as he views them. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. A critique of rajiv malhotra s being different nicholas f.
Opinion a rebuttal to rajiv malhotra, by an elite leftist goon activist a talk recently delivered by the selftaught social scientist at tiss devolved into a hail of accusations. The petitioners are believed to belong to the network of trust created by rajiv malhotra s book, the battle for sanskrit. Rajiv malhotras insistence on preserving difference with mutual respect not with. This voluminous book of 474 pages says that the traditional dharmic perspective of chaos as natural and normal. Defending hinduisms philosophical unity, the battle for sanskrit, and the newly released book academic hinduphobia. Rajiv malhotra born 15 september 1950 is an indianamerican author who, after a career in the computer and telecom industries, took early retirement in 1995 to set up the infinity foundation, which focuses on indic studies, and also funds projects such as columbia universitys project to translate the tibetan buddhist tengyur apart from the foundation, malhotra promotes a nonwestern view. May 02, 2011 rajiv malhotras book, breaking india it is hard to avoid the conclusion that islamic terrorism started with osama bin laden if one were to go by what the us politicians claim and what the media reports. Rajiv malhotras book, breaking india atanu dey on india. This phenomenon holds profound relevance in the lifestyle of millennials today. I have seen his videos and im waiting for my exams to finish so i can start on a book he has authored. I am posting here an excerpt from rajiv malhotras book.
Technology is available with us, the greatest challenge, however, is to change peoples mind. In this light, and so close to pentecost, i therefore am happy to call your attention to an essay partly about the holy spirit, posted just this week at beliefnet by rajiv malhotra, a learned. The very acts of recursion and reiteration after a quantitative threshold, impart upon the structure an unexpectable and inexplicable qualitative leap of. The book reverts the gaze of the western cultures on india, repositioning india from being the observed to the observer, by looking at the west from a dharmic point of view. Rajiv malhotra books showing 1 1 products of 1 products sort by. In his recently published book, indras net, author rajiv malhotra describes professor anantanand rambachan as the foremost and most influential exponent of what malhotra describes as the neo. Rajiv malhotras being different is a path breaking book filled with original perspectives on both indian and western civilizations.
187 1375 381 240 875 579 1529 64 1146 710 723 1351 271 1027 586 1470 574 796 1181 309 1470 1153 1202 966 564 1427 1398 1469 889 1287 1038